While reading the comments to a post by Drew McManus that I mentioned in my previous post, I came across a reference to a post that drew had written about the issue of having too many groups offering the same thing in a metropolitan area.
While Drew disagrees than in general there may be too much of this redundancy (as he responded) he does think there are some areas, like the Northern Virginia/Washington DC area he talks about in the post I linked, that do have a problem. Drew seems to think it’s a dangerous idea for mergers, but at the same time he understands that in the case above that might actually help. Anne Midgette’s snapshot of the German orchestral crisis post-unification would suggest the same.
But back to Drew’s points:
Although I was glad to see that there weren’t any duplicates between the four ensembles, they do have remarkably similar programming (but I give Alexandria a few extra points for programming more new works than their sister ensembles). If you’re familiar with that area, you’ll also know that all four ensembles perform within eight miles of each other and two of them even perform in the same venue.
Granted, Northern Virginia is a densely populated area but doesn’t it seem reasonable to think that four full orchestras performing similar works for essentially the same audience is simply too many notes?
I have a different idea–what would happen if, say, one or more of these orchestras actually turned into a non-Western Orchestra? Or what if the re-structuring made it possible to actually provide full symphonic works that were so Eurocentric?
For example, what if that Northern Virginia/DC area had, say, a full Arabic Orchestra, a full Chinese Orchestra, a full Mugham Orchestra in addition to the fourth full Symphony Orchestra?
There certainly wouldn’t be any overlap of programming, nor any duplicate composers in just one art music tradition.
I know, it’s a pipe dream–with the exception of special events American Orchestras don’t often program outside their 100 + year old niche of music from a region on this planet [Europe] that has less than a tenth of the world’s population. But I know I would be as excited, if not more excited to be able to hear a full orchestra perform the masterworks of Mohammed Abdul Wahhab, Fikret Amirov, or Lü Ji.
I guess I’ll have to wait until the ethnic population(s) of the US reaches the critical mass able and willing to support these non-Western Orchestras–or until this century’s version of the Ford Foundation Grants spearheads “a major boost to [non-Western] orchestras’ quality, length of season and sustainability by providing endowment capital for orchestras that were able to raise matching funds from their communities .”
I guess the question is, if Western Orchestras are having difficulties then how will the non-Western Orchestras fare? That’s what I’ve been trying to figure out and it is exciting to imagine the future! Right now, though–there aren’t too many notes or too few orchestras. Just not enough of the right balance of notes and orchestras.